We agreed that it was over

And the lines have all been drawn

Vows were made,

Began to fade, but now they're gone

Put your pictures in a shoebox

Put my gold ring in a drawer

I'm not supposed to love you anymore

Now Sherry says she's jealous

Of this freedom that I've found

If she were me, she would be out on the town

She says she can't imagine

What on earth I'm waiting for

I'm not supposed to love you anymore

Oh, I shouldn't care or wonder where you and how you are

But I can't fight this hurt inside my broken heart

I'm fighting' back emotions that I've never fought before

Cause I'm not supposed to love you anymore

Now I'm writing you this letter

And it's killing me tonight

That I agreed when you believed it wasn't right

And I couldn't sleep up on the bed

So I'm down here on the floor

Where I'm not supposed to love you anymore